Reality and the American Health Care Crisis
Posted in Illegal Aliens & Immigration Reforms, The Democratic Agenda on Health Care on November 30th, 2007 by MorningStarWhile the Democratic presidential candidates blather on about the American tax payer’s need to shoulder the burden for the estimated 43 million people in America who do not have medical insurance because of it’s increasing cost, very little has been said about who these people are or why the cost of medical insurance continues to increase.
A new report from the Center For Immigration Studies entitled “Immigrants in the United States, 2007: A Profile of America’s Foreign-Born Population,” is now available online to help clarify some of these questions.
According to this report, the immigrant population (legal and illegal) reached a record of 37.9 million in 2007 and immigrants now account for one out of every eight U.S. residents. Overall, one out of every three immigrants now in the U.S. is an illegal alien and more than 50% of all immigrants from Mexico and Central America are illegal aliens. Thirty-one percent of all adult immigrants currently in the U.S. have not completed high school compared to 8% of the native population.
33 percent of immigrant-headed households use at least one welfare program, compared to 19 percent for native households. Among households headed by immigrants from Mexico, the largest single group, 51 percent use at least one welfare program.
The poverty rate for immigrants and their U.S.-born children (under 18) is 17 percent, nearly 50 percent higher than the rate for natives and their children.
Overall, 33.8 percent of the foreign-born lack insurance compared to 13 percent of natives.
Immigrants now account for 26.8 percent of all uninsured persons in the United States. This compares to their 12.6 percent of the total population.
When the young (under 18) U.S.-born children of immigrants are included with their parents, the share without health insurance is 29.9 percent. The share of children who are uninsured is lower than for their parents mainly because the U.S.-born children of immigrants are eligible for Medicaid. Thus the inclusion of the U.S.-born children pulls down the rate for immigrants slightly.
The report concludes that the low rate of insurance coverage associated with immigrants is primarily explained by their much lower levels of education. Because of the limited value of their labor in an economy that increasingly demands educated workers, many immigrants hold jobs that do not offer health insurance, and their low incomes make it very difficult for them to purchase insurance on their own.
A larger uninsured population cannot help but strain the resources of those who provide services to the uninsured already here. Moreover, Americans with insurance have to pay higher premiums as healthcare providers pass along some of the costs of treating the uninsured to paying customers. Taxpayers are also affected as federal, state, and local governments struggle to provide care to the growing ranks of the uninsured. There can be no doubt that, by dramatically increasing the size of the uninsured population, our immigration policy has wide-ranging effects on the nation’s entire healthcare system.
In very simple terms, this report validates what has been common knowledge among many American citizens for quite some time. Illegal aliens using American hospitals and emergency care facilities as their own personal free clinics have forced the cost of healthcare to skyrocket across the nation because hospitals have little choice but to pass losses incurred by non-paying illegal aliens along to American citizens with health care coverage. Furthermore, as the cost of medical care has increased to cover the unpaid debts of the illegal aliens abusing the system, the cost of medical insurance has been forced up to meet these increasing costs. It would be entirely logical to assume that, with more than 8,000 new illegal aliens entering the United States every week, the problem will continue to grow worse, the cost of healthcare in the United States will continue to increase and the cost of medical insurance will get even higher.
Of the four leading Democratic candidates for president, John Edwards is the only one to pin the blame for rising health insurance costs on an identifiable group and he directs the finger of blame at the insurance companies themselves with the simple-minded allegation that their all-consuming greed and lack of competition are the primary culprits. Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama and Bill Richardson make no attempt to affix the blame for rising health insurance costs on anyone or any group. It’s as if the rising cost of health insurance in the U.S. is entirely inexplicable – a mystery with no known cause, possibly supernatural in origin, or in the case of Bill Richardson, possibly caused by same extraterrestrials whose fellow interstellar traveling companions crashed near New Mexico’s Area 51 so many years ago. Hillary Clinton leans strongly towards the implication that the problem is the result of racial disparity, but she avoids putting the blame for what she terms “Racial Health Disparities” on anyone in particular. Ironically enough, even though she blames no one for the problem, Hillary does point out that one-half of foreign-born Hispanics are uninsured, and that as the Latino population has grown in the United States, their health coverage situation has deteriorated and while the number of uninsured people in every other ethnic and racial group shrank between 1994 and 2004, the number of Hispanics without a regular source of healthcare grew from 29 to 31 percent.
The simple truth is that the United States has the most technologically advanced health care available anywhere in the entire world and more American citizens have health care insurance than ever before in the entire history of this country. Interestingly enough, if you go back up to the eighth paragraph of this posting an take the un-weighted percentage indicating the total number of immigrants without health insurance (29.9%) and calculate how many people that percentage actually represents among the estimated 42 million people in this country without health insurance you will discover that the answer (12,857,000) seems to be remarkably similar to the federal government’s estimate of how many illegal aliens are currently in the United States.
29.9% of 43,000,000 = 29.9/100 x 43,000,000 = 12,857,000
While it may escape the attention of the entire Democratic Party, or more specifically, the Democratic candidates for president, the obvious common sense conclusion that most of the people in this country have been aware of for years is that the presence of 12,857,000 freeloading parasites who have no qualms whatsoever about running up huge medical bills with no intention of every paying for the services they receive is definitely going to have an seriously negative impact on American health care. The hospitals and emergency care facilities that are required by federal law to provide free treatment to these illegal aliens are not reimbursed by the federal government for the services they provide, and ultimately they have no other choice but to pass along some of the costs of treating the uninsured illegal aliens to paying customers or go bankrupt. It logically follows that as the health care providers are forced to pass along these un-recovered debts to their paying customers (ie the American citizens), the cost of the medical insurance to cover the expanded cost of health care is going to also rise in direct proportion. It doesn’t take a brain surgeon to figure this out but it certainly helps if you aren’t a politically correct Democratic politician pandering to the illegal alien/Hispanic/Latino sub-culture who may or may not vote for you. In all honesty, I must admit that I don’t really believe the Democratic contenders are too dumb to figure this out for themselves, they are bright people who have had the benefit of a decent education and I am sure they know this information as well as anyone else. However, by giving them the credit of having at least an average intelligence, it then becomes logically obvious that they are being entirely deceitful.
The United States government already shells out more than $2 trillion tax dollars per year on health care. That includes the cost of health care coverage for all federal employees, elected officials, the military, Medicare, Medicaid and an assortment of tax payer funded health care entitlement programs such as the SCHIP program. A nationalized health care program covering every person in the U.S., by very conservative estimates, would triple that expense. Realistically, there is no credible way to estimate the increase in government spending if such a program were implemented. However, while the exorbitant cost of such a program might be impossible to estimate, the one inescapable fact we can be sure of is that a national health care plan in the United States would be entirely disastrous and the staggering cost, which would, of course, be shouldered by the American tax payer, could reduce the after-tax wages of every working American by as much as 40%. The quality of American health care would go straight into the toilet the instant that Doctors and hospitals no longer had to compete for customers by providing high quality care to attract customers who could easily go elsewhere for the services they needed. In the regulated environment of a nationalized health care program there would be little reward for technological medical advancement and as innovative new treatments ceased to be a source of profit the technological slide of American health care would start to make Nigeria’s health care system more attractive. Additionally, a nationalized health care system that supplied medical care to everyone that walked through the door regardless of their immigration status would be an attractive motivation for future illegal aliens to come here and participate in this great American free-for-all and the cost to the American tax payer would continue to escalate without control.
Obviously the answer to the problem of high health care costs is not to be had by the implementation of a nationalized health care program. The key to resolving this problem is the same as it is for any other serious problem – first you must identify the root cause. In the case of rising health care costs that root cause is blatantly obvious. We have 12,857,000 freeloading parasites that have no qualms whatsoever about running up huge medical bills with no intention of every paying for the services they receive. We can eliminate a full 30% of the cause for rising health care costs in America simply by enforcing immigration laws and enhancing border security. If this cost the American tax payers a trillion dollars or five trillion dollars we would be money ahead in the long run. The cost of health care would plummet, the cost of medical insurance would fall accordingly, the American tax payer would not be unduly burdened with unnecessary taxes and American medical technology would continue to advance unrestricted, and all of this would be made possible by the simple act of facing reality instead of burying our heads in the sand while pandering professional politicians make the problem even worse with stupid ideas that have obviously failed in every country where they have been implemented.
Technorati Tags
John Edwards,
Hillary Clinton,
Barack Obama,
Bill Richardson,
National HealthCare Plan,
SCHIP,
illegal aliens,
Democratic Party
